Spying On Your Employees

2009 September 14
by Grace Boyle

My girlfriend and I were catching up on the phone the other day when she mentioned her company was going to be installing video surveillance at the office. At first I thought, okay, it’s a big company so they need security surveillance.

She groaned and I could hear her rolling her eyes, “No, to watch us, the employees!” My eyes grew wide in disbelief and I almost laughed. Then I inquired exactly where would the videos be? She said the owners of the company want to keep a closer eye on the employees and she’s going to have a video right in her cubicle!

Who Monitors What?

I’m not surprised that 75% of employers monitor Web site connections.

3119891607_5c70175eac

Therein lies the fine line of watching over your employees and trust. Forbes talks about, “How to Legally Spy on Employees,” where their concern is heightened as technology has improved, risks have increased. Because of this, most corporations are now monitoring their employees closely. Many of my friends have social sites like Facebook and chatting capabilities blocked from their work computers. Some have to check in at a front desk, some have security and others have metal detectors. I’m not saying all that is wrong. Precautions, unfortunately, have to be taken especially in large cities.

According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, U.S. Organizations lose about 7% of their annual revenue due to fraud. Yikes. If you think you’re safe, maybe you should think again. Technology has made it easier for IT departments to become stealth and powerful in their surveillance abilities.

Are you going to cultivate or kill company culture?

Regardless of these precautions can you guess my girlfriend’s reaction to these videos? She said, “My jaw dropped to the floor along with all respect I had for my company when I found out. The small things to get me through the day will now be recorded and scrutinized. One word- extreme! Next move is job searching and finding a company who values their employees instead of instilling fear.”

Of course, this isn’t her only reason for wanting to look elsewhere and that’s another story, another time. However, it’s a large enough issue to feel like you need to be babysat when in actuality her work performance is among the top of the employees at the company. My experience is actually quite the opposite and maybe that’s why you find me largely happy and satisfied at my job. I’m not talking about security at a business in a large city. I’m talking about closely monitoring and instilling fear in their employees minds. Companies have a right, but in return, we have a right to know about monitoring. It’s safe to say I have nothing to hide while I’m at work, but I’m also required to be on blogs and social networks all day as my job.

Security expert, John Pironti of technology systems integrator Getronics says, “People aren’t necessarily more productive if there is a Big Brother atmosphere. But then again, sometimes just telling people you’re monitoring them deters a lot of bad behavior. “

I think that a company’s action around the information it collects about its employees may depend upon the corporate culture it wants to cultivate. Company culture and trust aren’t to be taken lightly. When given a sense of ownership it allows me to take pride in my work. I’m less constricted, I’m able to express my ideas and this helps my company grow and succeed. Isn’t that what a smart company is largely about?

What kind of company culture do you work in? Is there a high level of surveillance and rules? How does this make you feel?

Photo Credit

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • Share/Bookmark
  • SkinnyvSuit
    This is crazy. If I found out one day that the company I work for is installing a camera in my cubical I would get out. I just graduated from college but I really think it is important to find a job, especially a career, with a company that's values are aligned with my own. Company culture is so important to find out about before you choose a career. GenY's typically change a career several times with in their twenties, and I have a feeling it is because things like video surveillance in their cubical or just hating the company culture. I found this start-up "social recruiting" website http://koda.us where companies on the site create profiles that go beyond the details of a company website and trade magazine to describe what the company is really like to work for. Also they have current employees tab so that you can see the types of people you will be eventually working with. I feel like tools like KODA can really help job seekers find a place they can feel comfortable working for. I also think tools like KODA are so relevant because I think if you hate the culture and the people you work with, no matter what your job tile or description is that job is going to be miserable for you.
  • @SkinnyvSuit I agree with you. It seems so invasive and backwards really. Like others have said in the comments here, it makes sense to train your employees or maybe talk about new ideas to grow forward and instill trust versus spending so much money on equipment to spy.

    I really like the idea of Koda. Thanks for passing it along, I'm going to check it out!
  • I'd be interested in learning how the company went about making this decision. Outside of an employee theft problem or for security purposes (e.g. bank teller), I can't think of any way that this could be positive for employee morale. Like you said, today's employees want to work in a supportive, creative environment; promoting a culture of mistrust is not the way to achieve this.

  • @Jim My friend doesn't directly know their reasoning as I too, was curious. She said some of the VP's won't be around the office as much and they want to still "feel like they're around," to monitor, etc. I don't think it's a very compelling reason because like everyone else said, goals and performance can tell you a lot about someone's success not nit picking their every move on their computer.
  • The internet can be a big distraction. I understand why some employers trying to monitor what people do - because the Web and social media can be used just as much like TV as it can be used as a work tool.

    However, I definitely wouldn't want to work at a company that had a culture of survellience. I would want to work somewhere with creative, engaging work and an atmosphere of mutual trust.
  • @Brett The internet definitely is a distraction. But if the internet weren't there, maybe there would be another kind of distraction or reason to procrastinate. However, I'm with you about working with a company that is creating, engaging and has mutual trust.
  • Ted
    This type of surveillance/spying is just dumb. It is a tool for mediocre organizations to get mediocre results.

    Great places, the type of places that create stuff people talk about - they don't waste time on this. They give their people freedom and expect amazing results from them.
  • @Ted You're right and thanks for sharing that view point!
  • Wow, that sounds pretty intense. Watching your employees in real time basically means you don't trust them to do their work.

    I find this concept very strange. For example, who cares what your employees do as long as they hit their monthly goals? If the company has clear systems and milestones, then an employee can easily be measured by performance. Why survey them every single second of the day?

    This hugely destroys company culture because employees won't be able to have fun with one another anymore. Who would want to work for that company?

    ---

    What kind of company culture do I work in? Considering it's a startup, we are relaxed, fun, and young! Hahaha, that sounded so corny. I try to keep my team happy by sitting closely next to each other and just fooling around throughout the day. Gotta keep it fun!

    - Jun
  • @Jun Haha, I like how you describe your startup culture. I'm right there with you. On Brazen the conversation was continued on the post featured over there and I totally agree that performance goals should be the tracker instead of surveying them every moment of the day. That's tiresome and then negates creativity and fun.

  • Cameras in a cubicle...creepy, most definitely creepy. I'd say if you get to the point where you have to install cameras to "monitor" your employees than perhaps you have bigger issues than culture and trust.

    I will, however, note that a lot of companies don't allow folks onto sites like Facebook/chat/email not only for productivity but because of the security breach it opens itself up to. Think of all the viruses and whatnot that are downloaded to single home computers off these sites. If a company got one of those viruses off of a single computer and then it spread to a server or soemthing, that would just NOT be a good situation!
  • @Elisa On Brazen someone brought up a good point about the amount of money and effort the equipment will cost. What about efficiency training, new tools to implement and help employees and maybe reinstall some motivation?

    The online virus point is important and less about monitoring the employees, but taking care of infrastructure. Unfortunately, we look through each person who signs up with Lijit and have to visit some NSFW and potentially virus-ridden websites so our business computers are constantly looked at to fix and remedy (our poor IT dept).
blog comments powered by Disqus

  • Popular Topics

    Aging Blogging Brazen Careerist Business Career Change Choices Communication Consumer Goods and Services Contest Costa Rica Customer Service Dating Emotion Emotional Intelligence Employment Entrepreneurship freedom Friday Linky Love Friendship Gender Generation Y Glass ceiling GPA Halo effect Health and Science Hiring Inspiration Life Lessons Lijit Moving New York Times Optimism Psychology Relationships Small Business Social Media Social Sciences Success Surveillance sustainability Technology Travel Twitter Workplace Bullying Institute
  • Archives